| eArticles |
|
|
|
|
I Pledge to Make a Difference
New Insights Into the Effectiveness of Abstinence Pledges
by Brian Housman
|
Over the past two weeks there has been a firestorm of stories in the media
concerning a newly released study by Janet Rosenbaum on the
effectiveness of abstinence pledges among teenagers. Among the students tracked over a ten year period, 289 took a virginity pledge
with the other 645 not taking a pledge but having similar beliefs about
sex. The study showed that there was no difference between the two groups in the sexual activities
|
or number of sexual partners and
those who had pledged were less likely to use contraceptives once
sexually active. All of the students were said to be of similar
religious commitment.
Immediately, spokespersons on each side of the sex
education debate responded in full force. Proponents of abstinence-only education labeled the study
"inconclusive" and "deceptive." Those in the abstinence-plus camp
tauted the study as the first irrefutable evidence that school
abstinence-only programs don't work. And both sides are accusing the
other of a political agenda. As a parent, it can be difficult to wade
through the rhetoric, look at the facts, and then know how to
respond. As followers of Christ, we are commanded to
proclaim truth, but first we must understand what is true. With that
said, take a few minutes to look at the some of the findings of the study and
what the ramifications are for teenagers--more specifically for your
teen.
Standing On Its Own Merits
The headline from many media outlets has been that this study proves that teens who make an abstinence pledge are just as sexually active as their counterparts. An obvious fact of the study which the mainstream media have either ignored or were unable to decipher is that the study is restricted to religious students only. Instead of a cross section of all students, the study takes a slice from the pie and isolates it. That doesn't make the study flawed or any less important but rather more specific than some have reported.
A second observation from the study is that among religious teens there is no difference in their sexual activity. Both groups had the same rate of vaginal, oral, and anal sex, as well as the same STD contraction rate. Also, 82% of all pledgers who later became sexually active denied or forgot they ever made a pledge to purity. In other words, committing to an abstinence pledge does not appear to be a significant factor in curbing or preventing sexual activity.
The most startling evidence in the study is that those pledgers who become sexually active are far less likely to use any form of contraceptive. These religious students put themselves at a greater risk for pregnancy and STDs than their non-religious sexually active peers. Bill Albert, chief program director for The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy said, "What have we gained if we encourage young people only to delay sex until they are older, but when they do become sexually active, they don't protect themselves or their partner?" While the purpose of abstinence programs is not to "only delay sex," Albert's point is well taken.
The last factor of interest in the study is that those who pledged abstinence were about 17 years old when making the pledge and delayed sexual activity until they were on average 20 years old. Since there was no difference between the two groups, the deciding factor in the teens' approach to sexual activity isn't whether or not they made a pledge but rather their faith itself. In the end, it's not about the program but rather how active they are in nurturing their faith. Even the author of the study, Rosenbaum, observed of these religious teens, "They are less sexually experienced to begin with. Their friends are engaging in less risk behavior. Their parents also go to church and they are also choosing to go to church and to stay affiliated with evangelical Christianity."
|
Problems with the Process
Over the years I've seen a couple of flaws (there are actually more but for today I'm sticking with two) with the way most churches have attempted to teach sexual purity. One is that it is taught in an artificial environment. Many times students are taken away for a weekend retreat or camp or do a special series at youth group. It is like talking about God's design for sex in a vacuum void of real world experiences. Students hear truth but it is presented in an artificial and highly emotionally-charged environment. Many of the commitment ceremonies are done in the style of a public "altar call" where peer pressure and emotions abound. In that kind of environment it is hard to avoid any unintended manipulation. Lastly, students go home and rarely experience followup on the subject. It's as if, the church did their job and now we can all move on.
The second problem I see with many of the abstinence programs is they are carried out with little or no involvement from Mom or Dad.
|  | Here is one of the most important decisions a teen will
ever make--to live out their sexuality according to God's design--and
mom and dad are not present. In fifteen years of ministry, I've
only had two opportunities to talk
to students about sexual purity in which parents were in the audience.
I know of these flaws firsthand because these are mistakes I made myself as a church leader. It's only through years of poorly teaching the subject that I can see that it is time for a new approach. I'm tired of watching our teens make the same mistakes over and over quite possibly because they were not fully equipped to make a choice they could keep.
As parents we must stop relying on any
one program or curriculum to be the answer. As good as some programs may
be, they were never meant to the sole means of sex education, nor were they meant to silence parents who want to be involved.
I've know the creator of True Love Waits for several
years. I know Jimmy Hester's heart well enough to say he never set out to create a
program that would a magic bullet. Rather he was trying to help
churches begin the process of education, accountability, and commitment--one that supplements a parents job without supplanting it.
Setting A New Course
It's time that we as stop sitting idly by while other
handle the uncomfortable work of talking about sex. And it's time the
church empowers parents to be the spiritual authorities of their teens.
What if we all talked about these issues out in the open--at school,
at home, at church? What if the church presented the truth to students but with mom and dad as part of the process? What if we shared the whole story with
students, with all the possibilities, and trusted that the same Holy
Spirit that is active in us is also active in our teens? What if
parents took an active role in teaching their teens the role of dating
and how to have healthy friendships with the opposite sex? There is a role for all of us to play.
None of these
things in and of themselves will make a difference. Rather think of
each of them as a spoke on a wheel. All of them are required for the tire to be
balanced and to function according to its design. Your teen also has a
design. One given to them by God. One we help them discover
by doing all the right things not just the easy or convenient. I can't tell you what your discussion with your teen should include, how long it should be, or what stories you should tell. But I can tell you that as you share truth, with them from a heart that is overflowing with love and concern, that they right words will come.
| | | Brian is a husband, father, and writer.
He is also the founder of Awake to Life.
Be looking for his new Engaging Your Teen's World
to be released Summer '09.
| |
|
|
| |
See our Parenting Teen Videos on
|
 |
Thousands of parents already have.
|
| |
| |
|
You can now get teen culture updates on twitter. Start following us today.
|
| |
|
|
awake to life
po box 792
cordova, tn 38018
901.830.8813
|
|
|